CASE BRIEF US vs. Morrison FACTS: Christy Brzonkala (petitioner) in September of 1994, piece of music enrolled at Virginia technical school University was supposedly usurpationd by Antonio Crawford and James Morrison (respondents), in the mist of the rape Mr. Morrison and Mr. Crawford used several(prenominal) vulgar, boasting and degenerate remakes to Ms. Brzonkala. As result of the alleged rape Ms. Brzonkala became severely emotionally disturbed and depressed. Ms. Brzonkala eventually withdrew from Virginia technical school University. In 1995 Ms. Brzonkala filed a electric charge under Virginia Techs Sexual Assault Policy. A hearing was held and Virginias juridic Committee found that not enough evidence to vindicate Mr. Crawford. Mr. Morrison on the other contribute was found guilty of intimate assault and was sentenced to a prison-breaking from school for two semesters. Mr. Morrison Challenged this finis on two do was successful in acquiring the conviction set aside. Virginia Tech set aside the convictions of Mr. Morrison without intercommunicate Ms. Brzonkala. In December of 1995 Ms. Brzonkala make full suite against Mr. Morrison, Mr. Crawford and Virginia Tech in Federal District Court. The arse for her billing was that alleged rape by Mr. Morrison and Mr. Crawford was in assault of 42 U.S.C. Â§ 13981, the hysteria Against Act (VAWA) Mr. Crawford and Mr.
Morrison moved to dismiss the complaint on the curtilage that Â§ 13981s civil remedy was unconstitutional. DECISIONS at a visit place: The district court dismissed the complaint. The court of appeals support and Ms. Brzonkala appealed. effectual I! SSUE(s): Does the Â§ 13981, the Violence Against Act (VAWA) pass a federal agency under the craft clause? HOLDING: none Affirmed. REASONING: The VAWA statute does not fall under the commerce clause because in no way was the criminal action related to economic interstate activity. personalized OPINION: I agree with the Supreme Courts ruling in this regard. The district courts handout of Brzonkala complaint was puritanical under the...If you want to get a full essay, say it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com
If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper